Finance Matt May 30, 2025 0 Comments

The True Cost of Credit Card Points and Rewards [2025 Update]

But the real cost of these programs is often much higher than most people realize. Behind the scenes, someone always foots the bill for these generous offers—whether it’s through annual fees, higher interest rates, or even price markups passed down from merchants. Knowing who actually pays for these benefits is key to using rewards cards responsibly and getting the most from your spending.

How Credit Card Rewards Programs Work

Credit card rewards programs operate as powerful incentives, designed to keep you reaching for your card more often. Issuers team up with merchants and payment networks to offer you something back every time you spend. The rewards system is straightforward on the surface, but not all rewards are created equal. The structure, potential, and conditions all vary—and knowing what’s behind each option can help you make smarter choices.

Types of Credit Card Rewards: Points, Miles, and Cash Back

Nearly every rewards card falls into one of three main groups. Each has its own rules and typical value.

Points: Points are versatile, acting almost like a digital currency. You earn a certain number of points per dollar spent, which you can later redeem for travel, gift cards, merchandise, or statement credits. Some cards offer bonus points for spending in select categories, such as groceries or dining.
Miles: Travel rewards cards give you airline miles or hotel points. These fill a similar role to points but are best used for airline tickets, hotel stays, or travel upgrades. This type is popular with frequent travelers who can redeem at higher values through specific loyalty programs.
Cash Back: Cash back cards offer a direct, easy-to-understand value: a percentage of each purchase credited back to your account. Some cards offer a flat rate on all spending, while others provide higher rates for certain categories. The biggest draw here is simplicity; you know exactly what you’re getting.

Want a deeper dive on the core reward types and comparisons? Types Of Rewards Credit Cards at Bankrate breaks down the differences and which style may be a better fit for your spending.

Earning and Redeeming Rewards

Earning rewards often seems as easy as swiping your card, but maximizing returns takes a little savvy. Most rewards cards earn you a base rate on every dollar, and higher-tier cards offer bonus rates on things like dining, gas, or groceries. Many cards also feature sign-up bonuses if you meet a spending goal within the first few months.

Here’s how most cardholders boost their rewards:

Use the right card for the right purchase: Match spending with category bonuses.
Combine multiple cards for double-dipping or category stacking.
Hit sign-up bonus thresholds: These can be worth hundreds—if you can pay off the balance each month.

Redeeming rewards isn’t always as simple as earning them. Each program has unique rules around redemption:

Redemption values vary: With points or miles, a point can be worth more or less depending on how you use it. Travel bookings may get you more value than gift cards or merchandise.
Minimum redemption amounts: Some issuers limit when you can cash out, such as needing at least 2,500 points for a gift card.
Blackout periods and restrictions: Travel rewards, in particular, can come with blackout dates or partner airline limitations.

Even programs with high advertised returns can have fine print. Review your options and weigh redemption choices carefully. For an overview on earning, redeeming, and common restrictions, see A Beginner’s Guide To Credit Card Points.

By understanding these core mechanics, you can squeeze greater value from your rewards and avoid common pitfalls that eat into your returns.

Who Really Pays for Credit Card Rewards?

Credit card rewards often feel like a perk just for you. But these benefits don’t appear out of thin air. Instead, there’s a whole system behind every point, mile, or dollar you earn. Someone has to cover the expenses—and it goes far beyond the banks and card issuers. To understand who truly pays for your cash back or travel upgrades, you need to look at the role of merchants, the impact on people who don’t use rewards cards, and what this all means for everyday shopping.

Merchant Fees and Price Increases

Every time you use your credit card at a store, the merchant pays a fee for accepting that payment. These are known as interchange fees (paid to the card-issuing bank) and network fees (paid to Visa, Mastercard, etc.). While interchange rates vary, in the U.S. they usually land between 1% and 3% of the total transaction amount. Luxury and premium rewards cards often come with even higher fees—sometimes above 3%.source: Bankrate’s explanation of merchant and network fees.

Merchants rarely absorb these costs. Instead, they build them into their prices, which means every shopper pays a little more—whether they use a credit card or not.

Key points:

Interchange fees: The biggest part of merchant costs, collected by the bank that issues your card.
Network fees: Smaller, covering card network operations (Visa, Mastercard, etc.).
Built-in costs: Retailers raise prices to offset these fees, so all customers share the burden.

A study from Kellogg shows U.S. merchant fees are among the highest globally, with most stores forced to increase prices to keep up with rewards funding and other card processing costs. Read more about these hidden price hikes in this analysis on Kellogg Insight.

So when a rewards card offers 2% or 3% cash back, merchants often pay just as much—or more—to accept that card. This cycle leads to higher sticker prices for everyone, not just those collecting points.

Impact on Non-Reward Card Users and Lower-Income Consumers

The credit card rewards system not only raises prices for everyone but also hits hardest for those who don’t, or can’t, use cards with perks. Many people use basic cards, debit cards, or cash—either by choice or because they don’t qualify for premium products.

Here’s how the uneven effect works:

Non-reward card users: These shoppers pay the same higher retail prices but receive no rewards in return.
Lower-income households: People in this group are less likely to qualify for rewards cards and thus help subsidize rewards for higher spenders.
Economic gap: This creates an income transfer, where lower-income and non-rewards shoppers help cover costs for wealthier rewards card users.

It’s like the reverse of a loyalty program—where the people who need savings most get the fewest perks, but help pay for others’ travel points or cash back. Research by the Federal Reserve finds these patterns add up to real dollars, with some studies suggesting lower-income households effectively transfer hundreds of dollars a year to those with rewards cards. For a detailed review, see Who Pays For Your Rewards? Redistribution in the Credit Card Market (PDF).

This uneven playing field is one reason financial experts warn about the side effects of chasing card rewards. While rewards programs can be a smart way to earn back on planned purchases, the hidden costs often fall where you least expect them.

Annual Fees, Interest Rates, and the Real Value of Points

Understanding the price tag on credit card rewards means looking beyond what you earn at checkout. Annual fees, interest rates, and redemption choices shape the real value those points and miles deliver. While perks can look attractive, fees and interest can quietly erase gains. Here, we explore how to calculate what your rewards are worth—and the risks that come with chasing them.

Calculating the Value of Points and Miles

Not all points and miles have the same worth. Their value changes based on how you redeem them. Some redemption options can double the value, while others give you far less than advertised.

Let’s break down what you might actually get:

Travel Redemption: Many premium cards offer the best value (often $0.015 to $0.02 per point) when you book flights or hotels through their travel partners. For instance, 50,000 points could cover a $750 flight—meaning your points are worth 1.5 cents each.
Gift Cards and Merchandise: These usually give less value per point. A $25 gift card might cost you 3,000 points, making each point worth only about 0.8 cents.
Statement Credits or Cash Back: This is the most flexible option but tends to offer lower value, typically between 0.5 and 1 cent per point.

Redemption rates from sources like The Points Guy’s May 2025 valuations show how quickly value adds up—or disappears—depending on your choice. Always check the math before redeeming.

Many travel experts recommend aiming for 1.5 cents or more per point when booking travel. Anything less, and you may be better off taking a simple cash back card instead. For a breakdown by loyalty program, check out NerdWallet’s 2025 points and miles valuations.

Common Pitfalls: Overspending and Debt Risk

Reward programs encourage you to use your card for nearly everything. It’s easy to chase extra points by spending more, but those habits can backfire fast.

Here’s what to watch for:

Annual Fees: Some rewards cards charge fees from $95 up to $550 or more. If you don’t redeem enough rewards or maximize perks, these fees cut into your gains. Choosing the right card and weighing the fee against annual benefits is key. Capital One unpacks this in their guide to credit card annual fees.
Higher Interest Rates: Rewards cards almost always have higher Annual Percentage Rates (APRs) than basic cards. The average credit card interest rate in America hovers above 20%, according to LendingTree. If you carry a balance, interest charges can erase any rewards you earn for months—or even years.
Overspending for Points: The promise of a big sign-up bonus tempts many to spend more than they normally would. This can push balances higher, making it tough to pay off monthly.

A simple example: You earn $300 in rewards one year, but pay $99 in annual fees and $250 in interest by not paying your balance in full. Your net “reward” is actually a loss of $49. When credit cards tempt you to stretch your budget, the cost can stack up fast.

Key ways to protect yourself:

Redeem points for high-value travel, not low-value cash back or gifts.
Only use rewards cards if you can pay your balance in full each month.
Compare annual fees to the card’s estimated yearly benefit, especially if you’re considering premium products. Cards with smaller fees can provide plenty of value if the perks fit your lifestyle (see the list of best credit cards with annual fees under $100).
Don’t justify unnecessary spending to reach sign-up bonuses.

Fees and interest are silent partners in every rewards program. The best returns come only when you manage spending carefully and treat points as a bonus on purchases you’d make anyway.

Policy Debates and Proposed Reforms

Behind every credit card swipe, there’s a network of rules, fees, and politics shaping what both consumers and businesses pay. As the costs tied to rewards programs rise higher each year, many leaders, merchants, and consumer advocates have started to question whether the current system is fair—or even sustainable. Multiple policy debates and reform proposals are now in play, focusing on who pays, how much, and what payment choices should look like in the future.

Proposals to Cap Merchant Fees

Rising merchant fees are at the heart of the rewards debate. Retailers claim these fees—especially those linked to premium rewards cards—drive up prices, impacting every shopper. Policy experts and lawmakers have responded by pursuing fee caps and regulatory changes.

Here’s what’s happening:

Credit Card Competition Act: This bipartisan proposal aims to cut interchange (or “swipe”) fees by forcing more competition between networks on each card. Supporters say this would let merchants pick lower-cost options and save consumers money at the register. Early analysis suggests it could reduce processing costs, though banks argue it may also shrink available rewards. Learn more about key details in the Credit Card Competition Act of 2023.
Direct Fee Caps: Recent proposals from the Federal Reserve looked at capping swipe fees for debit transactions. While initial suggestions were lower, the final limits ended up higher than many retailers wanted, mainly after strong lobbying from banks. More info can be found in the debate over capping swipe fees.
Global Comparison: Other countries, such as Australia and the EU, have capped merchant fees—and seen rewards offerings shrink. U.S. leaders weigh these examples, asking how to lower costs without wiping out perks consumers value.

Most proposals focus squarely on lowering the cost of accepting card payments for businesses. But there’s a tradeoff. Lower fees would likely mean fewer card perks or smaller rewards. The real challenge is balancing broad consumer savings against the perks that drive credit card loyalty.

For a deeper look at the costs of payment processing and how these fees shape the market, check out this guide to credit card processing in 2025.

Encouraging Debit Card or Alternative Payment Use

With the true price of credit card rewards coming under more scrutiny, there is growing interest in steering consumers toward lower-cost payment options. Debit cards, cash, and digital wallets often cost retailers less to process, helping to keep prices down.

Efforts to promote these alternatives include:

Bank-Led Initiatives: Many banks highlight the benefits of debit cards, pitching them as simple, budget-friendly options. They use onboarding programs, education campaigns, and targeted communications to encourage new account holders to choose debit over credit. Strategies to make your debit program best-in-class outline some of the approaches that work.
Retailer Incentives: Some merchants offer discounts or loyalty bonuses when shoppers use debit or preferred payment types instead of credit cards. This not only saves the business money but can help shoppers avoid the temptation of overspending or racking up interest.
Marketing and Consumer Education: Financial brands have rolled out campaigns to promote debit and contactless payments. These efforts aim to make debit cards “top-of-wallet” by focusing on convenience, security, and real-time account control. Insights on growing debit usage are detailed in these strategies to stimulate debit card usage.

Encouraging people to shift from credit to debit could take some pressure off the system, reducing hidden markups caused by rewards funding. But since rewards cards have a strong grip on many consumers, it may take continued education and creative incentives to make real progress.

Overall, while credit card rewards aren’t disappearing, the push to cap fees and promote alternatives signals that change is on the horizon. Choices made now could reshape the balance of perks, costs, and payment options for years to come.

Conclusion

Credit card rewards offer extra value to many users, but these perks come with bigger hidden costs that affect everyone—often in ways most shoppers don’t see. Whether it’s higher prices in stores, added fees, or the chance of expensive debt, the true cost of earning points goes far beyond simple math at checkout.

Smart card use means looking at both the benefits and the broader impact. Before chasing new rewards or sign-up offers, consider who pays and who gains. Ask yourself if those extra points are worth the price paid by others across the system.

The future of rewards may change as new policies and fee limits are considered. Until then, make sure your card habits support your own goals, not just the business of earning the next bonus. Thanks for reading—share your thoughts or experiences with rewards below, and stay tuned for new updates on this fast-changing topic.

Share this content: